• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
Baker's Theory
  • What’s Cookin’
  • Recipes
  • Instagram
  • About

How to Make Butter

December 30, 2019 by Alex

Butter makes a wonderful gift for the holidays, and it couldn’t be easier to make. All you need is some heavy whipping cream and a standing mixer. I also recommend a fine mesh strainer. 

You can also flavor your butter with garlic, chive, plain salt, or cinnamon and brown sugar! 

Another fun idea is to use butter tins or presses to make fun shapes. We have had our butter in the shape of a lamb for Easter or a tree for Christmas!

This will make about a pound of butter (which is the same as four sticks). 

Ingredients

1 quart heavy whipping cream

1 tsp sea salt

 

Optional flavorings

Garlic and chive

Cinnamon brown sugar

Red chili flake

Honey lavender

 

Instructions

Pour heavy whipping cream into a standing mixer bowl. Add sea salt. Mix on medium-low speed using the whisk attachment. Allow to mix for about 30 minutes. 

*The mixture will go through several changes. You will first have the initial heavy cream liquid getting whisked. As it aerates, it will become whipped cream. As you continue to whip the whipped cream, the solution “breaks,” and becomes a viscous mixture of liquid and solid. As it continues whisking, the solid will harden and become yellow. The liquid is buttermilk and can be used to make batters for pancakes, waffles, or chicken. 

Once the butter has formed, remove it from the bowl and place it in a fine mesh strainer. You can either reserve the buttermilk for other recipes or discard it. Gently press the butter with a sheet of wax paper to drain it of excess buttermilk trapped inside air pockets. 

Then remove from strainer and wrap the butter in wax paper, placing it in a bowl to chill for at least an hour. (You can use it immediately if you desire!)

*If flavoring butter, you may add your flavorings after the solution breaks and proceed as usual. 

Filed Under: Basics, How to, Recipe

Previous Post: « How to Roast Tomatoes
Next Post: Mini Boston Cream Pies »

Primary Sidebar

Hey, you hungry?

I'm Alex! I'll make you something! I love to hang out in the kitchen with a buddy bellied up to the counter, ready to eat! I experiment in the kitchen with recipes from around the world! I like to know the science behind food, cooking, and baking. I believe in using the produce in season and wholesome foods. I love "putzy," complicated recipes and making nearly everything from scratch! Read More…

Pizza Dough and Dinner Rolls

Hiiii. Spring is here! Everything is so lush and green now and I am in heaven with it. Asparagus is the definitive spring vegetable, and I’ve had it on the mind since my mom told me she was making it with scalloped potatoes and ham for Easter. As fresh and springy as asparagus may be,…

Read More

Hot Off the Stove

  • Ginger-Garlic Chicken and Rice Lettuce Wraps
  • Pineapple Basil Drop Scones
  • “Ooh Mommy!” Umami Summer Salad
  • Chocolate-Filled Hawaiian Malasadas
  • Maui Garlic Fried Noodles

Copyright © 2025 Baker's Theory on the Foodie Pro Theme